The government’s hopes of urging employers into positive action in recruitment with the Equality Act are being dampened by industry experts who have announced that it is unlikely to help.
The Equality Act, which states that candidates from under-represented groups can be given preference by employers as long as they are of equal suitability to the other candidates, is due to become law in October after being passed in Parliament last week. In this way employers should be able to increase the diversity of their workforces.
However, experts are now warning of the difficultly of determining when individuals can be considered equally qualified or not. The guidelines offered by the Court of Justice that candidates can only be favoured when they possess ‘substantially equivalent merits’ to others, provide an uncertainty, it is said, which make it hard to see employers making use of their new power.
For senior level appointments it is thought to be particularly difficult to apply. A partner at the law firm Eversheds, Audrey Williams, stated that for senior roles career histories are so varied that comparisons are complicated. Similarly she noted that claims of unlawful discrimination from unsuccessful candidates may arise, resulting in expensive compensation awards.
Martin Tiplady, Human Resources director at the Metropolitan Police and a supporter of the use of positive action, insists the Equality Act could still work, as long as employers are firm about their objectives. She also explained that measures such as fast-track training for ethnic minority officers have resulted in a rise in the percentage of non-white officers from 2% to 9.5% over the course of 9 years.
This dispute may be in vain, though, as it was confirmed by Mark Harper, the shadow minster for the disabled, that a Conservative government would not bring in the positive action provision.
Become a Recruitment Genius
The induction process can be a daunting prospect for both the manager and the employee, with lots to remember from…
Making A Job Offer
This is one of the best parts of the recruitment process, as you are able to give the candidate the…
Effective Reference Checking For Prospective Employees
Reference checking is typically considered time-consuming and ineffective. However this is generally because companies adopt the wrong approach. Recruitment Genius…
Illegal Interview Questions
As an employer there are plenty of questions you are entitled to ask at interview. However, there are many questions…
Effective Interview Techniques
Whilst interview techniques will vary depending on the amount of time you have and the position you are recruiting for,…
Shortlisting Candidates for Interview
Whilst short-listing can be a time-consuming process, it is also an exciting moment when you get to meet the potential…
Could Application Forms & Career Portals Actually be Damaging Your Recruitment Campaign Prospects?
Career portals start with the best of intentions – to differentiate you as an employer of choice, underline your employer…
10 Tips To Improve The Success Of Your Online Recruitment Advertising
Online recruitment has revolutionized traditional advertising. You can now truly measure your return on investment and identify the most effective…
Secrets To Online Recruitment Success
Online job sites are arguably the most effective way to reach a wide range of candidates simply because they are…
Choosing The Best Online Job Boards
If you do not choose the best online job boards, then your recruitment campaign runs the risk of immediate failure.…
Selecting The Best Online Recruitment Company
The good news is that the age of expensive, poorly targeted newspapers and print media is pretty much dead. But…